Winds Of Change In Argentina: New President Appoints Experienced Team

Por Alejandro Chafuen: Publicado el 2/12/15 en:


“Buenos Aires,” the name of the Argentine capital, translates into “Good Airs” or “Good Breezes.” The hot summer days that are approaching in this South American city are not particularly appealing, but the recent election of Mauricio Macri to the presidency, is making many feel that they are in a political spring. Some observers are forecasting that the election signals the end of populism. “XXIst Century Socialists,” on the other hand, argue that the election is a partial set back and a return to “neo-liberal” and crony capitalist days. The new cabinet, appointed with extreme speed, can give us a sense of what might follow.

Let’s start with the economy. The people chosen by President-elect Mauricio Macri, Alfonso Prat Gay, Pedro Lacoste, Rogelio Frigerio, and Federico Sturzenegger, to lead the ministries and agencies in charge of the Argentine economy are shrewd operators with ample experience in the public and private sectors. Their knowledge of how the Central Bank and other state-owned banks and agencies operate is an essential asset to this transition. During my lifetime, (I was born in 1954), not a single elected president who was not part of the Peronist party was able to finish his mandate. That’s not to say that they were all destabilized by the Peronists alone; one of them, Raúl Alfonsín (1983-1989), did it mostly to himself. His team implemented an easy money policy, which destabilized the economy, forcing him to call for early elections.

Argentina’s president-elect Mauricio Macri will take office as president of Argentina on December 10. (EITAN ABRAMOVICH/AFP/Getty Images)

The knowledge that Prat Gay, Lacoste, and Sturzenegger have of the web of interventionist regulations currently used to control most aspects of the Argentine economy will help the next administration to carefully assess any malfeasance conducted by the Kirchner government during these last weeks and until they take charge on December 10. Martin Lousteau, chosen to become ambassador to the U.S., belongs to the same club as the rest of the economic team. He also worked for the Kirchners and following his political instincts more than his economic understanding, greatly increased the dreaded export taxes, but was chosen due to his political clout.

Like good technocrats, the new team will be able to dazzle their audience and other policy players with numbers and figures. Yet having knowledge of data and economic statistics is not enough to avoid missing the goal of achieving financial stability and sounder monetary policies. The track record of Argentine “monetary experts” has not been good. In this case, pragmatism, of a non-dogmatic, Keynesian fashion, will be the norm. Prat Gay was head of the Central Bank in the early years of Nestor Kirchner’s administration (2002-2004), and Pedro Lacoste was his deputy. Lacoste’s consulting firm, Tilton Capital, is named after the estate of the late John Maynard Keynes. Only when compared with 21st century socialists can this team be considered “neo-liberal;” neo-Keynesian is more appropriate, but still much better than neo-Marxists like the departing Axel Kicillof.

What changes will we see first? I expect that soon most prices will be determined by the market process. There will be a gradual and uneven liberalization of the prices currently set and subsidized by the government (for instance, a train ticket costs 20 U.S. cents, which I estimate is 10 percent of its real value). I forecast that President Macri will respect his commitment to letting the price of the U.S. dollar and other foreign currencies be determined by the market, while asking his team of technocrats to try to smooth major fluctuations. But this will only be possible if the government puts its fiscal house in order and pursues a sound money policy.

To accomplish this goal, I expect that President-elect Mauricio Macri will seek major support from international financial institutions. He will show signs of responsibility by negotiating an agreement with Argentine creditors (the “holdouts”) and pushing for less politicized relations with most countries. Transparency in these first deals, divulging commissions and fees paid to financial brokers and legal advisors will indicate if there is a chance that positive change in Argentina is possible.

The new Minister of Energy, Juán José Aranguren, the recently retired head of Shell Oil Company, was one of the few in the business sector who, during this last decade, dared confront the Kirchner administration not only with words but also with lawsuits. In economics, he champions free markets moderated by social policy; his principled stances made him a darling of local free-market think tanks.

As Minister of Homeland Security, Patricia Bullrich will have a daunting task. But she does not lack the courage. As minister of labor in a previous administration under President De La Rua (1999-2001) she was the only one to really confront the Peronist labor unions. Originally from the “left,” Bullrich became a staunch defender of republican institutions both in Argentina and abroad (with Macri, she will fight for the freedom of Venezuelan political prisoners). Eugenio Burzaco is the new head of intelligence. Burzaco created the police of the city of Buenos Aires in order to counter the more politicized national (federal) police. Teamed with Bullrich, they will be a formidable team. They are committed to combatting narco-trafficking and the many criminal endeavors supported by its profits. Germán Garavano, who with Burzaco wrote “Mano Justa,” a book that received the Sir Antony Fisher Award from Atlas Network in 2005, is the new Minister of Justice. In no area does Argentina score so low as in respect for rule of law and justice. So these appointments are of immense importance.

In addition to justice and security, Argentina faces major challenges in the educational arena. Esteban Bullrich, the new Minister of Education, will bring his knowledge, innovative spirit, and integrity to the national scene. He developed and tested his skills as secretary of education in the city of Buenos Aires. He understands the theory and practice of education.

In Labor, Jorge Triaca (Jr), the son of one of the few moderate labor union leaders in Peronist history, played important roles in Fundacion Pensar. Pensar is a think tank that started as a state policy network, collaborating with think tanks across Argentina and Spain. It later became the official public policy ideas generator for the Macri-led political organization (PRO). Jorge Triaca left Pensar when elected to Congress. Due to his knowledge, big tent approach, and demeanor, he is one of the most admired politicians in Argentina today.

Argentina confronts major problems in economics, rule of law, security, and education. The team assembled by Macri is outstanding on many fronts. In my area of expertise, economics, I anticipate that interventionism will continue. This interventionism will be less political but, as it always favors some at the expense of others, it will not be less risky. In international affairs and global positioning, Argentina will show a very different face, much more civilized, respectful, and modern. All in all, a much welcome change for Argentina, the region, and the world.


Alejandro A. Chafuén es Dr. En Economía por el International College de California. Licenciado en Economía, (UCA), es miembro del comité de consejeros para The Center for Vision & Values, fideicomisario del Grove City College, y presidente de la Atlas Economic Research Foundation. Se ha desempeñado como fideicomisario del Fraser Institute desde 1991. Fue profesor de ESEADE.

Carta abierta al nuevo gobierno

Por Alberto Benegas Lynch (h). Publicado el 29/11/15 en:


Si no aparece algún estropicio adicional del gobierno en funciones que pretenda empañar lo que se ha decidido en las urnas por el voto mayoritario, nos habremos librado de un aparato estatal que no solo ha degradado instituciones fundamentales del sistema republicano sino que ha deteriorado en grado sumo todos los indicadores de la economía.

Esto es indudablemente para celebrar. Sin embargo, dada la bipolaridad de muchos argentinos en cuanto a pasar de la euforia a la depresión, debemos evitar este zigzagueo que ha ocurrido repetidas veces en la decadente historia argentina de las últimas largas décadas. Esto viene ocurriendo desde al golpe fascista de los años 30 que pretendió una Constitución corporativa y estableció el control de cambios, el impuesto progresivo, la banca central, las juntas reguladoras y la embestida contra el federalismo fiscal, un estatismo que fue mucho más acentuado a partir del peronismo y sus imitadores donde el Leviatán estrangula libertades esenciales.

Ahora se presenta una oportunidad de enderezar las cosas aunque más no sea parcialmente. El clima del que no salta es un inglés debe sustituirse por meditaciones calmas y sustanciales.

Es cierto que en el nivel político no puede articularse un discurso que vaya más allá de lo que la opinión pública puede digerir. El problema de fondo es educativo, pero no debe caerse en la ingenuidad de pensar que es suficiente una buena gestión por parte de profesionales competentes puesto que no queremos un campo minado bien gestionado, ni siquiera se trata de seguir con un campo minado sin la lacra de la corrupción. De lo que se trata es de remover las minas.

En este sentido, es insoportable un aparato estatal sobredimensionado. Es imprescindible eliminar funciones incompatibles con un sistema republicano, no simplemente podar porque como en la jardinería la planta crece con más vigor. Resulta indispensable cortar el fenomenal gasto público y centrar la atención en las funciones esenciales de todo gobierno que opera en una sociedad abierta.

Lo que no se hace en los primeros meses no se hará aunque el primer tramo esté cubierto por fundadas denuncias de corrupción del gobierno anterior radicadas en la Justicia a través del debido proceso y cubierto por las medidas saludables respecto a la dictadura venezolana y el inaudito memorándum del sonado caso iraní vinculado a las masacres que son de público conocimiento.

La decencia y las buenas intenciones son condiciones necesarias pero no suficientes para que nuestro país vuelva a ubicarse a la vanguardia de las naciones civilizadas, como cuando venían nuestros ancestros a hacerse la América debido a que las condiciones de vida eran mucho más atractivas que las de Suiza, Alemania, Francia, Italia y España.

Entonces, no se trata de hacer la plancha y administrar la bomba de tiempo existente y operar con la misma estructura estatista financiado con más deuda, sino de remover cuanto antes el peligro al efecto de transferir recursos a los bolsillos de la gente y así brindar el mejor nivel de vida, especialmente para los más necesitados.


Alberto Benegas Lynch (h) es Dr. en Economía y Dr. en Ciencias de Dirección. Académico de la Academia Nacional de Ciencias Económicas, fue profesor y primer rector de ESEADE durante 23 años y luego de su renuncia fue distinguido por las nuevas autoridades Profesor Emérito y Doctor Honoris Causa.